Username or Email Address
Do you already have an account?
Forgot your password?
  • Log in or Sign up

    VWVortex


    The Car Lounge
    Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
    Results 1 to 25 of 65

    Thread: Battle of USA 5-speed beaters: Cavalier vs. Escort vs. Neon

    1. 06-28-2008 10:21 AM #1
      During their heyday, I've rented each of these, of course with their standard Hertzvisget automatics.
      In these days of looking for more modest transportation, anyone have experience with the five speed versions willing to share?





      Modified by chazbet at 10:23 AM 6-28-2008

    2. Geriatric Member ATL_Av8r's Avatar
      Join Date
      Oct 17th, 2002
      Location
      Gapiana
      Posts
      42,820
      06-28-2008 10:22 AM #2
      damn....that made me realize I haven't seen a 1st gen Neon in YEARS
      MemeGate 2012 - First Responder, post #2

      Quote Originally Posted by .skully.
      Mike, quote me in your signature

    3. 06-28-2008 10:22 AM #3
      First, this should have been a poll. Second I was very happy with my 98' Neon and wish I never had gotten rid of it.

    4. Member ZoomBoy's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jun 3rd, 2002
      Location
      Toronto
      Posts
      11,013
      Vehicles
      2003 Civic SiR
      06-28-2008 10:23 AM #4
      Cavalier FTW, and I use that term very lightly here.

    5. 06-28-2008 10:26 AM #5
      Ask Hertz, not TCL. Those cars SUCK. And I mean SUCK.
      Given the choice though, I'd pick the Escort.



      Modified by SickWrathTerror at 10:27 AM 6-28-2008

    6. 06-28-2008 10:27 AM #6
      Would appreciate direction how to make a poll, not having initiated any posts.
      But, isn't a civilized discussion topic just as fun?
      Just to offer additional fodder for comments: Lots of threads exist on what to buy for <$x,000 where x is a small integer.
      Those of us in the mid West tend to see more USA metal, have neighbors/family who work in the industry, etc.
      What if we ruled out the typical Japanese/Euro choices, for whatever reason? Could we get a decent ride from the big 3?


      Modified by chazbet at 10:36 AM 6-28-2008

    7. 06-28-2008 10:40 AM #7
      I know people with Cavaliers and Escorts . Cavalier
      300000 mile cars plus, with maintenance, not to shabby 99% hwy though.
      The Escort is real good but he's only at about 120000, but so you know
      they're real easy to steal. They stole his but he got it back.

    8. Senior Member
      Join Date
      Mar 24th, 2001
      Posts
      26,940
      06-28-2008 10:50 AM #8
      What about:

    9. 06-28-2008 11:32 AM #9
      The Neon was by far the most fun of the trio.

    10. Member Art Vandelay's Avatar
      Join Date
      Dec 20th, 2005
      Location
      STL
      Posts
      9,869
      Vehicles
      SVO
      06-28-2008 11:35 AM #10
      The GT version of the previous generation Escort (before the one pictured) is easily one of, if not the most fun to drive car for the price. The newer ZX2 is similar. I've heard good things about some Neon models, but I've never driven one. The Cavalier shouldn't even be on your list.
      JSW TDI, Mustang SVO, et al.

    11. Member onebadbug's Avatar
      Join Date
      Dec 21st, 2002
      Location
      Youngstown, Oh
      Posts
      4,151
      Vehicles
      96 Cherokee 4.0, 82 Rabbit Truck
      06-28-2008 11:37 AM #11
      I went to the drag strip last week. I saw absolutely NO Escorts, a couple unimpressive Cavaliers, and several Neons that really suprised me.
      I vote Neon
      Next edit by onebadbug; tomorrow at 10:13 AM.

      What you get isn't always what you see.

    12. Banned
      Join Date
      Feb 4th, 2008
      Posts
      1,874
      06-28-2008 11:38 AM #12
      I've driven all three. and trust me.. you do not want the cavalier..
      I would choose the Escort because the Neon I drove barely moved at all, maybe there was something wrong with it, I'm guessing it had a 0-60 of like 15 seconds...
      The Escort did feel kind of peppy.

    13. Banned WhistlerYOW's Avatar
      Join Date
      Oct 14th, 2004
      Posts
      10,165
      06-28-2008 11:40 AM #13
      Neons drive like go-carts but the first gens had lots of problems.
      Cavaliers drive like boats but always got the job done and were decently reliable, I see tonnes still kicking with high miles.
      The Escort is the only one I haven't driven but I've always heard good things about their reliability...

    14. Member deepspeed12's Avatar
      Join Date
      Mar 26th, 2002
      Posts
      6,299
      Vehicles
      Silverado, Forester
      06-28-2008 11:42 AM #14
      I would go for an older body style Escort Gt, I always loved these cars.

    15. Member GTI2Slow's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jun 22nd, 2007
      Location
      New Hampshire
      Posts
      2,351
      Vehicles
      MK5 GTI, Ford Escape Ecoboost 1.6 4WD
      06-28-2008 11:42 AM #15
      I had a escort ZX2 5MT, it was a great DD. The transmissions fail if you beat on them. And the motor would easily last 200K+ miles.

    16. Member bhtooefr's Avatar
      Join Date
      Dec 22nd, 2005
      Location
      Newark, OH
      Posts
      17,340
      Vehicles
      99.5 Golf TDI 2dr, 92 Miata, 11 TerraTrike Path 8
      06-28-2008 11:45 AM #16
      The Cavalier is a Cavalier, the Neon blows headgaskets, and the Escort is an American-built version of an Australian rebody of a Mazda 323.
      (Of course, with some Ford engines in there. But from what I've heard, the CVH engine is fairly reliable, and there's always the GT/LX-E/Mercury Tracer LTS if you want a Mazda engine, too.)

    17. 06-28-2008 12:47 PM #17
      Ive driven all of them with a 5 speed, and honestly the cavalier IMO was the easiest and most comfortable to drive. Granted its not fast and its not fun, but its reliable and with regular maintenance can go for a long time!
      That being said though if it was me Id go for a 5spd one of these


    18. Member a1veedubber's Avatar
      Join Date
      Oct 15th, 2004
      Location
      Stuart Iowa
      Posts
      2,894
      Vehicles
      More than is reasonable
      06-28-2008 02:20 PM #18
      At least with the Cavalier you can get some Rally Sport emblems for the quarter panels and pass it off as a rare hipo sports coupe! Anyone remember that fellow posting his on here a few years ago?
      Seriously though, of the cars pictured I would take the Cav as a beater. Its GM and I know those cars inside and out. If there is a little wiggle room in bodystyle & year I would definitely go with a later Escort GT or ZX2. My wife had a 94 GT and it was an excellent sporty driving, fuel efficient, reliable car.
      Matt K

      Motorcade of Mediocrity!

    19. Member two.twoliter's Avatar
      Join Date
      Apr 4th, 2004
      Posts
      1,727
      Vehicles
      1991 Volvo 745 n/a
      06-28-2008 02:30 PM #19
      If you're looking for something fun to drive, I would go for a 98-99 neon r/t without hesitation. Probably the best overall sport compact of the time, especially for the price. Many of the suspension and steering parts of the acr but without the koni dampers for a more compliant ride.
      If you want fuel economy, a sohc 5 speed neon from 98-99 is rated at 29 city/ 41 hwy which is awesome for a 132 hp car carrying 2400 lbs. Dohc cars should still get mid-high 30s on the highway.
      And neons are perfectly reliable if you avoid the automatic and get one with the mls headgasket (most will have this installed by now) Neons aren't the most refined cars, but neither are a lot of CL favorites. They are, however, a complete ball to drive.


      Modified by two.twoliter at 1:32 PM 6-28-2008
      Sold: 86 240 DL 4MT+OD, 00 Protege ES, 87 325e, 93 S-10, 91 CRX Si, 99 Neon ACR, 90 Accord Coupe.

    20. Member xdre's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jun 11th, 2001
      Location
      Indianapolis
      Posts
      10,834
      06-28-2008 06:32 PM #20
      Quote, originally posted by bhtooefr &raquo;
      the Neon blows headgaskets,

      They blow the OEM plastic headgaskets. The mls replacement doesn't blow. I'd take it in a heartbeat over a Cavalier, but the Escort's a tougher call.

    21. Member bhtooefr's Avatar
      Join Date
      Dec 22nd, 2005
      Location
      Newark, OH
      Posts
      17,340
      Vehicles
      99.5 Golf TDI 2dr, 92 Miata, 11 TerraTrike Path 8
      06-28-2008 06:35 PM #21
      To be completely honest, I'd lean towards the Escort, even if the Neon in question was repaired.
      First things first, I never see 1st-gen Neons around any more... and they were VERY plentiful when they were new. That indicates that something's up. OTOH, I see 11tybn 2nd-gen (not so many 3rd-gen, though) Escorts, and most of them are older than the 1st-gen Neons.
      Second, I'll admit, I've got an anti-ChryCo brand bias. And, a somewhat pro-Mazda one, and underneath the bodywork, the Escort is a Mazda.

    22. Member xdre's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jun 11th, 2001
      Location
      Indianapolis
      Posts
      10,834
      06-28-2008 06:39 PM #22
      Quote, originally posted by bhtooefr &raquo;
      First things first, I never see 1st-gen Neons around any more... and they were VERY plentiful when they were new. That indicates that something's up.

      Right. The plastic headgasket. After a potentially major repair like that, a lot of goodwill is used up, and people are more likely to sell the car if anything else comes up (like, say the timing belt replacement at 105k). Cars that have multiple owners in a relatively short time are more likely to be disposable.

    23. Member bhtooefr's Avatar
      Join Date
      Dec 22nd, 2005
      Location
      Newark, OH
      Posts
      17,340
      Vehicles
      99.5 Golf TDI 2dr, 92 Miata, 11 TerraTrike Path 8
      06-28-2008 06:43 PM #23
      But, even something like that still indicates that the Escort would be, on average, a better idea, if the Neons are abused by third and fourth owners that don't care about them...

    24. Member Benjamin.'s Avatar
      Join Date
      Nov 12th, 2001
      Location
      Hanover, PA
      Posts
      9,857
      Vehicles
      1997 Miata, 2010 Prius, 2005 Grand Caravan
      06-28-2008 06:44 PM #24
      I haven't driven one in ages, but I used to have a blast driving a girlfriend's 150hp Neon Expresso 5spd.

    25. 06-28-2008 06:46 PM #25
      I used to have a 5 speed DOHC Neon in high school. It was a fun little car. Never really had any issues with it at all.

    Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •