Nice post groggory
This will simplify a lot of the confusion about the differences between replacement options. I'm also thinking now that i should get a shield to dress up the bay.
#1
There seems to be a lot of different methods of working on the coil pack problem so I'm going to take a stab at making a definitive reference. Please chime in if I post any misinformation, partial information (chime in with further info), or additional products or links that may be useful.
Note: I will be editing and adding extensively to this post as I get all my information together.
Coil Pack Harness Replacement/ Repair Kits
INA Engineering 4 wire Coil
7/31/09 - $187 shipped
* Splice into the factory harness
* Does not go all the way back to the ECU
* Uses Superior Wire quality to prevent the cracking issue from resurfacing
* Uses flex boots similar to what is found on the 2.0t to prevent cracking at the connectors
* Does not cover up any of your coil pack area. Easy to work on coil packs
USP Motorsports individual Coil Pack Replacement
6/11/10 - $39
* Splices into the factory harness
* Does not go all the way back to the ECU
* Uses superior wiring to OEM
Coil Pack replacement harness
6/11/10 - $50.27
* OEM part
1J0 971 658 L
* Replaces the harness all the way back to the ECU
* You will need tools to de-pin the ECU
Home-Made Version of the tool pictured above for repinning
It is two safety pins taped together. Apparently works fine and may just save you in a pinch.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Coil Pack Heat Shields
034 Motorsports Coil Cover
6/14/10 - $30
* Bolts to back of valve cover
* Available in: Raw stainless, Brushed stainless, or powdercoated
* Requires some trimming
ECS Heat Shield
6/11-10 - $65.01
* OEM Part #
8L9 121 659
* Uses snaps to button it up around the coils and wires
* Covers the wires of all the coil packs like a flap.
* Uses OEM style heat shield material
Coil Pack Cover off MkV 2.0t
4/28/10 - $18.89
Part # 06F 971 824C
* Can fit the 1.8t coil pack loom with a little trimming
--My personal choice (shown w/ INA 1.3 spacers and TSI coils)
Ignition Coil Pack Shield
6/11/10- $58.95
* Appears very similar to the ECS heat shield
1.8t coil pack rubber boot
Part # 4B0906102 (for 2 pin/ injector)
Part # 4A0906102 (for 4 pin/ coil pack)
4/28/11 - $4.25 / $6.11
The Audi OEM heat shield is P/N is 8L9-121-659
Price ????
Custom cover by forum user 'goodhews'
4/19/10 - $15
* Made of a mild steel
* Covers coil packs and wiring
* Attaches using bolts on back of valve cover
Heat Reflective Tape
~$15
Wrap your wiring in this and it will dodge most of the heat.
Wrap your wiring in this and also buy the rubber boots for your coil pack connectors and I think you'd be pretty golden.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DIY Links for Coil Pack Repair
How to install the foil snap type shield
How to repin the ECU and do a full rewire of the coil packs
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Coil Packs
* 4 Bolt Style
Part #
Price
Distributor
* 1.8t Push Down Style
Part #
Price
Distributor
* Conversion to mk5/mk6 pushdown style
The use of the mk5 or mk6 pushdown coil is a new trend in the 1.8t tuning community which has shown to create a stronger spark and has allowed the use of a larger spark plug gap. This larger gap allows for a better burn and thus improved fuel economy, improved engine idle, and the ability to use more aggressive timing which will result in more power.
The mk5/6 coils will push straight into any 1.8t valve cover as is, but they will stick out the top significantly. This installation makes long term reliability questionable at best. To meet this demand a few aftermarket shops have created billet adapters to adapt the various 1.8t valve covers to fit these coils.
Long term reliability of mk5/mk6 coils in a 1.8t platform is not yet known, but as of this writing these coil packs have usurped the famed 'Hitachi Bolt Downs' as the coil to get for the 1.8t platform.
On a side note, mk5/6 coils are less expensive than Hitachi Bolt Down Coils. The caveat to this is that adapter plates are really required to make a proper seal and fit.
Mk5/6 coil packs are compatible with all 1.8t motors that utilize a 4 pin coil pack harness. The 3 pin harness in early 1.8t motors is not compatible with the mk5/6 coil packs.
Bolt Down Plates
* IE Plate for all 1.8t valve covers
$69.99 for all four adapters w/ mounting hardware
* 034 Plate for square 4 bolt style valve covers
* 034 Plate for 2 bolt style push down valve covers
Coil Packs
VW/Audi Mk6 Coil Pack (Revision F)
Part # 07K905715F
Price: $18.95
Distributor: partshaus.com
Mk6 Coil Pack
RED MKV FSI Coil Packs - 06E 905 115
BLACK MKV FSI Coil Packs - 07K 905 715 F
BLACK MKV TSI Coil Packs - 06F 905 115 F
BLACK MKVI TSI Coil Packs - 06H 905 115
Eldor Mk4 Coil Pack (version ??)
Distributor: IE
Part #:
Price: $29.99
'E' Bolt Down Coils
* OEM Part #
Distributors
Price
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Related
Coil Pack Guide
Last edited by groggory; 11-11-2011 at 07:34 PM.
#2
Nice post groggory
This will simplify a lot of the confusion about the differences between replacement options. I'm also thinking now that i should get a shield to dress up the bay.
#3
Nice![]()
| œ Orchid Euro Importation œ |
Currently driving or working on...
| '93 Fox 16v - PVW| '03 Sprinter - Build Thread | '99 Polo Greenland Polo - Build Thread | '85 Scirocco Storm RHD - Thread | '85 Polo RHD | '75 Swallowtail - Build Thread |
| '99 Lupo 1.4TDI-S | '82 Caddy | '90 Jetta 8v | '96 Volkswagen LT35D | '02 GTI 337 | '03 GTI 20v |
| '09 Aprilia RS125 | '81 Kawasaki AR80 | '78 Honda CB125 | '59 NSU Quickly | '64 Honda Cub C65 | '65 Honda Cub C105 |
| Trek Madone 6.9 |
#4
good post. I still don't understand the idea of putting a metal shield over your valve cover. You would think that would keep the heat in and cause the wires to crack sooner. They do look nice though.
#5
I think the metal shield would protect against direct radiated heat from the exhaust manifold/ turbo..which is the biggest killer.
I think of it this way...If I put meat in the broiler, what happens when I cover it with aluminum foil and what happens when I leave it open? Open = crispy delicious outside (dead coil wires). Closed = Very hot meat but soft and juicy. But even with that said, I think the OEM style heat shield is still the right way to go. I have no data to back this up. We need to get someone in there with a thermocouple and take readings at a few different spots over various driving conditions.
#6
Updated with DIY link for full replacement (aka the ECU full wiring harness in my initial post)
#7
Hey look, I found an old FAQ thread I made back in the old good ol days.
So free ^^bump^^ for me
My Build
My FAQ / DIY Thread -- Look here for 90% of the questions you have
FS: New in box, primer'd 20AE body kit (front+rear valences and side skirts) -- PM me for details
FS: Fiberglass 20AE replica spoiler. No scratches. Reflex Silver.
#8
Stole this pic but it's an MKV coilpack harness cover which fits mkiv's with minor trimming
part num: 06F 971 824C
![]()
Last edited by dknl; 04-28-2011 at 07:40 PM.
#9
Don't forget about these:
http://www.ecstuning.com/Search/4B0_906_102/ES261669/
http://www.ecstuning.com/Search/Rubb...mmet/ES363903/
![]()
#10
^^^ It sure does. Nothing a Dremel can't handle. Greg, pick which ones to go up above and afterward I'll delete this Post like the W/M one.
-J
![]()
#11
My Build
My FAQ / DIY Thread -- Look here for 90% of the questions you have
FS: New in box, primer'd 20AE body kit (front+rear valences and side skirts) -- PM me for details
FS: Fiberglass 20AE replica spoiler. No scratches. Reflex Silver.
#12
#13
My Build
My FAQ / DIY Thread -- Look here for 90% of the questions you have
FS: New in box, primer'd 20AE body kit (front+rear valences and side skirts) -- PM me for details
FS: Fiberglass 20AE replica spoiler. No scratches. Reflex Silver.
#14
#15
#16
groggory i really want pass by & drop u a fancy beer case![]()
thank you for such informations,to you and all who enrich our knowledge![]()
#17
My Build
My FAQ / DIY Thread -- Look here for 90% of the questions you have
FS: New in box, primer'd 20AE body kit (front+rear valences and side skirts) -- PM me for details
FS: Fiberglass 20AE replica spoiler. No scratches. Reflex Silver.
#19
A cheap solution is to wrap the wiring harness with heat reflective tape:
![]()
projectsatin: malone tuned K04 1.8T with methanol injection
#20
Are you guys who've replaced the whole wiring harness noticing cracks all the way back to the ecu? Based on the level of PITA associated with changing the whole thing I think I may just take the INA route.
#21
You rule.
I need 2 of those heatshields. The audi part is stupidly expensive.
#22
I have an unused ina repair harness for sale.
fyi
My Build
My FAQ / DIY Thread -- Look here for 90% of the questions you have
FS: New in box, primer'd 20AE body kit (front+rear valences and side skirts) -- PM me for details
FS: Fiberglass 20AE replica spoiler. No scratches. Reflex Silver.
#23
_________________________________________________
12 Golf R RB 4-Door Sunroof - APR Stage 3
11 Routan
HS Tuning - www.hstuning.com
#24
Sorry...already sold.
When the wire insulation starts to crack you will get more misfires and weaker spark...which causes misfires and partial burns ... which causes carbon buildup in your cylinders, valves, exhaust manifold, turbo, o2 sensors, and exhaust. Lots ofthere.
If you can see the wires becoming brittle, cracking, or just not in good repair...just replace them. It'll save you headaches when you wonder what the real problem is down the line.
Also, cracked insulation can make the coil packs work harder, thus burning them out and costing you money.
My Build
My FAQ / DIY Thread -- Look here for 90% of the questions you have
FS: New in box, primer'd 20AE body kit (front+rear valences and side skirts) -- PM me for details
FS: Fiberglass 20AE replica spoiler. No scratches. Reflex Silver.
#25
Should you add the new 2.0t coilpacks and adapter plates to this thread?
#26
My Build
My FAQ / DIY Thread -- Look here for 90% of the questions you have
FS: New in box, primer'd 20AE body kit (front+rear valences and side skirts) -- PM me for details
FS: Fiberglass 20AE replica spoiler. No scratches. Reflex Silver.
#27
I ended up buying an OEM harness for $50, then just cutting and splicing it in instead of running the new wires back to the ecu; I didn't want to fu(k with de-pinning those plugs.
Anyway, no more misfires! I can now run BKR7E's gapped to 0.030 with stock coilpacks and not get misfires (before I had to keep it down to 0.026).
#28
My Build
My FAQ / DIY Thread -- Look here for 90% of the questions you have
FS: New in box, primer'd 20AE body kit (front+rear valences and side skirts) -- PM me for details
FS: Fiberglass 20AE replica spoiler. No scratches. Reflex Silver.
#29
^I'll dig it out of the trash later on and take a look. I wanted to disect it anyway.
#30
Excellent info, great writeup!
04.5 BMP GLI 1.8T
"It's not what you drive, it's how you drive it" -Clarkson
#31
Bump for attention whore status
^^ Updated some part numbers
My Build
My FAQ / DIY Thread -- Look here for 90% of the questions you have
FS: New in box, primer'd 20AE body kit (front+rear valences and side skirts) -- PM me for details
FS: Fiberglass 20AE replica spoiler. No scratches. Reflex Silver.
#32
#33
For those guys running the IE coil adapters with 2.0T coils, is there a preference or difference between the FSI and TSI coils?
#34
My Build
My FAQ / DIY Thread -- Look here for 90% of the questions you have
FS: New in box, primer'd 20AE body kit (front+rear valences and side skirts) -- PM me for details
FS: Fiberglass 20AE replica spoiler. No scratches. Reflex Silver.
#35