The masses have spoken. Down with DSG!
Anyone have some Porsche info on how their PDK is selling? Just curious.
#36
I appreciate them both and have both currently. DSG is great on normal cars like our Golf and JSW but I prefer a manual on sports cars. Maybe I'm old fashion but the manual is just more fun to me.
2012 TTRS: Daytona Gray, Tech Pack, Heated Alcantara, CF Mirrors, Nexon CF Steering Wheel, DG Rear Valence
GIAC Stage 2+, AWE SwitchPath + cat-deletes, AWE FMIC, H&R RSB, MSS Sport Springs, HRE P40, AWE Boost Gauge, Tinted Tails and Reflectors, OSIR Coolant Tank CF Shield
Winter/Track Wheels: Borbet LV5
#37
The masses have spoken. Down with DSG!
Anyone have some Porsche info on how their PDK is selling? Just curious.
2011 Orca Black Q7 S-Line
2012 Phantom Black TTRS (Tech Pack, Sport Exhaust Titanium Pack, Heated Seats)
1999 Spec Miata #46
#38
I'm going to talk a bit out of asz here, but I would bet PDK is selling quite well for Porsche...but...I think there's more that meets the eye than just mere sales.
At least here in Texas, for every car enthusiast who drives their sports car for its virtues and may dabble in trackdays/autocross, there's three who buy them for the badge and prestige and never even floor the car to see what she'll do. I would imagine that PDK sells well to this crowd, an automatic with cred so to speak. I would imagine there are some track rats who really dig and can exploit the PDK but sales wise, I still think they're the minority.
Another factor is that Porsche's production numbers have really been trimmed from a few years ago. A quick search of various dealer websites around the country will show a much smaller inventory of cars ready for delivery. When I bought my Cayman S in late 2006, there was literally 5 or 6 hundred on the ground around the USA in various configurations. Nowadays, my local dealer(s) will have only 20-30 cars total on the lot and most of those will be Cayennes or Panameras. I bet most lot cars are ordered with PDK to make them appeal to a broader audience.
Houston, TX
2012 Porsche Carrera 991
#39
Scott, that could be true. But you could also look at it that enthusiasts will buy the car with the options that make it the quickest. And that's why if DSG was offered on the RS, I would have a hard time passing on it. Nissan GT-R is another car where it's standard.
I understand the whole "skill" and "driver connection" attached to the manual, but when I buy a performance car I want the performance. Now, the RS has definitely helped refresh my shifting and braking skills.
But if I was building a racecar, and a sequential gearbox was an option (that I could afford, and there wasn't a severe weight penalty), that's what I would choose. The goal is to go faster than everyone else.
Here's me talking out of my asz...I think Audi drivers are insecure about how BMW and Porsche drivers view our cars. Getting a manual helps alleviate that insecurity. (I'm sure this will go over well.)
2011 Orca Black Q7 S-Line
2012 Phantom Black TTRS (Tech Pack, Sport Exhaust Titanium Pack, Heated Seats)
1999 Spec Miata #46
#40
#41
I test drove a TTS and thought the DSG was pretty awesome. I would have definitely thought twice about a 7-speed DSG if it was available on the TT-RS. And I've only had manual trans cars...
2012 TT-RS in Suzuka Gray
#42
In a way, yes. You absolutely feel the seemless acceleration(and deceleration) in the TTS. That, to me, is a rush. The system is so good, that even though I love my RS with 6sp manual, I know the DSG is superior.
"People who care that much about performance in a road car"???...you mean all of us? As enthusiasts, aren't we supposed to care? I care.
Not to start WW3...I love the manual transmission. I'm just saying the DSG is worth consideration from all, and I would probably choose it.
(Thanks, Marty. I knew we would finally agree on something.)
2011 Orca Black Q7 S-Line
2012 Phantom Black TTRS (Tech Pack, Sport Exhaust Titanium Pack, Heated Seats)
1999 Spec Miata #46
#43
2012 Daytona TT-RS / Tech / ASM Recaro Advanced SR-7 / Alcantara / HRE C93 9.5 x 19 Brushed Polished and staggered.
#44
Actually no, I'm not after that last 0.1s of anything. What I really wanted was a 5-cylinder coupe with a manual transmission that handles well. The fact that it has 360hp is I guess a bonus but as I've found out in my first month with it, that power is not very accessible and some days is far more frustrating than wheeling around with my lowly 225hp mk1. But the noise certainly makes up for it![]()
#45
Yeah, to each his own. The car is awesome no matter what transmission. But I'm not just talking about the 0.1s differences. I truly think the experience of your foot on the floor, pulling back the right paddle, and hearing the backfire as it upshifts without a hiccup is intoxicating. Then decelerating around a curve, retracting the left paddle, and listening to the programmed throttle blip was addicting.
So I guess with all that inaccessible hp you won't be opting for an APR or GIAC ECU flash, eh?![]()
2011 Orca Black Q7 S-Line
2012 Phantom Black TTRS (Tech Pack, Sport Exhaust Titanium Pack, Heated Seats)
1999 Spec Miata #46
#46
2012 TT-RS in Suzuka Gray
#47
I will give you this, full throttle, no-lift upshifts in the R8 were pretty epic.
Oh man that's a hard one... I go back and forth between this is more than enough power and if I chip it I'll either never be able to use it or end up in jail, and then I think, screw it, as soon as APR has their stage 3 setup available I'm getting it![]()
#48
2011 Orca Black Q7 S-Line
2012 Phantom Black TTRS (Tech Pack, Sport Exhaust Titanium Pack, Heated Seats)
1999 Spec Miata #46
#49
#50
"backfire as it upshifts?" does the rs let out some good popping and gurggle when shifting? Be it manual or dsg... I thought you would have to install the miltek pipes that delete the secondary car to get that sound/pops as I think Jeremy mentioned in some other post.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
#51
FWIW, "backfire" probably wasn't the right word, but anyone who's driven a DSG TTS knows what I mean. Word on the UK TT forum was that the RS with DSG sounded even more awesome on upshifts. I imagine this is even more pronounced with a louder exhaust.
The manual doesn't have the same type of sound on shifts.
2011 Orca Black Q7 S-Line
2012 Phantom Black TTRS (Tech Pack, Sport Exhaust Titanium Pack, Heated Seats)
1999 Spec Miata #46
#52
You guys are just in denial.
Aside from the "experience" of the DSG that I described above, we all are proud of the potential performance of our cars. When someone asks you about your car, don't you tout all of it's virtues?
"Yeah, it's got 360hp and is all wheel drive. It's got 370mm Brembo brakes. Zero to 60 is 4.1." No one here boasts about this stuff (in good taste, of course)? Come on.
Anyway, people would always ask me about the DSG on the TTS with that "It's an automatic?!!!" attitude. I was (and still am) proud to explain that it's a paddle actuated manual that is better than the 6 speed manual. Now, my friends are like "I'm glad you finally got a manual", but I tell them the DSG was better.
2011 Orca Black Q7 S-Line
2012 Phantom Black TTRS (Tech Pack, Sport Exhaust Titanium Pack, Heated Seats)
1999 Spec Miata #46
#53
2012 Daytona TT-RS / Tech / ASM Recaro Advanced SR-7 / Alcantara / HRE C93 9.5 x 19 Brushed Polished and staggered.
#54
#55
These guys are nearby and are carrying the cat-bypass pipes so they can probably get the full milltek system.
http://g-werke.com/products.cfm
#57
#58
#59
http://www.fourtitude.com/news/publi...cle_7475.shtml
It's my car!!! MUAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!
SUCK IT!
- Jeremy -
Misano TT RS w/ Tech Pkg, Aluminum Pkg, Sport Exhaust, Alcantara, Heated Seats and Black/Red Wheels + Milltek secondary decat pipes
#60
#61
#62
q u a t t i v e
T T - R S
Monza / Titanium / Tech / Heated Seats / Leather
#63
TTRS Plus - Jeremy's car
2012 Daytona TT-RS / Tech / ASM Recaro Advanced SR-7 / Alcantara / HRE C93 9.5 x 19 Brushed Polished and staggered.
#64
Anyone outside of North America considering ordering this car now that its available?