Highlight to read.
In the books, yes. Renly is killed by the shadow thing, but you don't see where it comes from. This particular section takes place a little later in the book to take out someone else. It looks like they are just combining the 2 events.
Last edited by dashrendar; 04-24-2012 at 02:52 PM.
Isn't the black smoke demon baby thing the one that kills Renly, right in front of Brienne and Cat? Hence, everyone blames them for it? Smokebaby has to be born first in order for that to occur, n'est pas?
I could be wrong of course, but this is how I remember it going down.
If a new show airs Sunday night but you have not watched but come in here and whine about spoilers then you are a moron. What do you think the flurry of posts are about, a new recipe for brownies?
But there are people that have read the books, know what is going to happen, and come in here and spill the beans. That is a no-no IMO.
I expect people to discuss the show up until the last episode that was aired. Anything beyond that should not be discussed IMO. IMO since this the "Movies and Television" forum there should be limited mention of the books.