I've heard the autos are decently reliable on the TSX, but the issue is more with the powerband, the K24 needs to be revved, and auto transmissions don't like to rev, so the car feels wayy slow with an auto. The good news is that the manual is a great transmission.
I was looking into a TSX in 2009, right when the new ones came out, comparing the two. I thought it was a good, solid car, but not really super quick, a super good handler, or super fuel efficient. It seemed like a good compromise, but a tad boring. The first gen is a little more noisy inside than the second. Both generations have cheap-feeling leather, too, if you're a dashstroker.



