Cant say anything about the Asymmetric 2 but I did have the Asymmetric (two sets on a BMW 335I).
I liked them. Not very loud and handling was very good. Tires didnt roll onto the sidewalls in spirited turns. I had Michelins before that and then had the Pilot super sports after.
The Michelins are definitely louder and they had better handling when it is dry but the Eagles were outstanding in the rain. I lived in Arkansas when I had the eagles and had no problems in the heavy rains there. Had to take someone to the hospital 23 miles in one of those storms where people pull over and wait it out. I was able to get tot he hospital very quickly and the handling was never an issue. After it was over I realized I was driving a lot faster than I should have been but it was a life or death emergency and she lived. I have neve had any tire handle that well in the rain but I havent ttried all that many.
I am in Arizona now so I went back to Michelin Pilot super sports.
If you live anywhere that it rains on a regular basis then I would consider the Asymmetrics. They are a good all around tire. Not the best dry but they make up for it when it is wet.