Very tough question and excellent thread
I listed my EVO IX MR the other day and after a few days of thinking, maybe this is the car for us, at this time. Have a family of three now, and something less convenient would get driven less, and likely wouldn't give me the smiles-per-mile the Evo does.
This is the reason I purchased it. I just really yearn for a car that is scary fast. Something you revere and respect, and are actually scared to lay it on! The Evo is fast, and I feel totally confident driving it fast...and the awesome part, even in weather conditions. Another reason I bought it!
I'll list a few cars that I can't get off of my mind and have long been there:
Evans LM (saw one of these at a gas station, outside of Road Atlanta. ****ing death. Had night vision...yeah, and it was forward facing..lol. Wonder what this was used for? lol)
Ferrari 348 would be the happy, and content car... if it were faster. But it's not.
In the end, I am looking for $200k speed for a $50k bill. Just ain't gonna happen!
So, back to the Evo... Seriously is a damn bargain for what you get
Maybe I am content and just don't know it yet
Reducing all my needs to one car, it'd be the Mitsubishi Evo, probably a VI-VIII. Black, white, or dark grey. Probably an MR. I'd need track suspension and wheels/tires, winter or gravel suspension and wheels/tires, and DD suspension and wheels / tires.
Looking for a ratty Miata? My '90 is for sale.