Fiance and I are moving on to new phones.
She works at AT&T and this tends to be our trend... New phones every 6 months or so.
The white one is a fresh one from Apple, has not been used.
And still has a year of AppleCare+ on it that can be transferred to the new owner.
(The original white one was dropped, and this is its AppleCare+ replacement. Not a refurb, it is brand new. They just don't give you a new box, so it is opened.)
The black one has been my personal phone since I bought it in March of this year.
Still under Apple's one year basic warranty.
Has had a case, and screen protector on it since the moment it came out of the box, and it shows.
(both removed for pictures)