Changed the oil two weeks back and when I checked the oil level and proceeded to wipe off the dip stick the orange handle just obliterated into tiny little pieces.
I decided to opt for Gruven's aluminum replacement, 'cause it's aluminum and won't degrade and fall apart over time like plastic. It works I guess, but it doesn't have quite as good of a seal as the OEM unit and it gets hung up when trying to pull it to check the oil level (I guess that's why their site says to give it a 1/4 turn when removing ). I also picked up one of their VeeChain key chains to stack onto the order... It's a nice piece, but it wasn't exactly finished with burrs hanging all over the place and it shipped without a key ring .
Overall it was a little pricey for some mediocre goods, but the main problem with the dipstick has been corrected so I'm happy.