All my o2's are in the downpipe so no killing sensors but i am only running one pre-cat sensor as thats how the tune is and used the second bung for my wideband. Daily driven no issues or codes nothing like that
#36
the 2 banks are to keep balance between the 3 left cylinders from the right ones, one bank has 2 fwd cylinders and one rear and in the other bank you get 2 rear and 1 front which run considerably hotter due to the exhaust manifold being there etc. so that is the treason why vw splits the banks
on the turbo tune the back 3 cylinders are ran a bit richer to keep them colder compared to the front ones I read here in the forums.
Last edited by huichox4; 09-07-2012 at 04:49 PM.
#37
All my o2's are in the downpipe so no killing sensors but i am only running one pre-cat sensor as thats how the tune is and used the second bung for my wideband. Daily driven no issues or codes nothing like that
-JAMES-
Daily Drive /Beaten/Built /UM Turbo R - VR NATION
#38
i have a lean situation under startup/idle that eventually clears once lambda kicks in Hiccups and little annoyances about this tune vs on my r32t that i just crashed a month ago that had the um software. i have a video of said lean issue etc. I was in contact with jeff through texts from the minute i knew ide be buying this r32 and it had c2 software. I wanted to bring my um ecu and change it in the dudes driveway, he kinda persuaded me to drive it on the way home and report on what i found. Honestly... a few hiccups in the tune to me isnt a big deal but in the 700+ miles of highway and city it is just starting to piss me off and i cannot wait to put my united motorsport ecu in.
WunderWagens June 10,2012 in Gilbert, PA... 2nd year http://www.wunderwagens-show.com
UnitedMotorsport r32 cam flash... get one
My Turbo .:R Build Thread
WunderWagens Vortex Forum
WunderWagens Facebook
#40
^truth. Both cars ran 2 in the manifold. On a eip mani and now a pAgparts
WunderWagens June 10,2012 in Gilbert, PA... 2nd year http://www.wunderwagens-show.com
UnitedMotorsport r32 cam flash... get one
My Turbo .:R Build Thread
WunderWagens Vortex Forum
WunderWagens Facebook
#41
Well, I figured my B1 S1 sensor might be getting cooked because of tuning problems.
I have replaced the MAF with a new one.
Replaced the factory fuel pump.
Replaced spark plugs
Checked for charge pipe leaks, none found
Replaced both 02 sensors, replaced the B1 S1 three times
Checked the heating circuit voltage to the B1 S1 sensor and it is within spec, OHM test of sensor is withing spec.
Wanted to check the circuit from the 02 to the ECU but don't have the pin-outs for the ECU
The issue is the B1 S1 02 works sometimes and sometimes it just goes off line........ logging 001 shows lambda just goes to 0 and I get a fault code for the B1 S1 sensor.
Light throttle, engine bucks, surges and in general runs like crap when this happens. I figured it might be tune
I'm at a loss
Last edited by Arizman3; 09-08-2012 at 11:31 PM.
#42
Hardware problems like having the sensor 1" after the exhaust port?
I "ruined" a limited edition .:Race car
R32 Turbo Build Round 2! Faster, Lower, Smoother.
Integrated Engineering
#43
Look most turbo users are having this same problem, why isn't anyone posting the one true solution? What is supposed to be done to get this issue resolved. I am running two o2 stock pre-cat sensors in the exhaust manifold. My car is running is running like dog **** It shutters under lots of load. I used to have two open loop sensors in there and my car ran better but was dumping a **** ton of fuel. My manifold is a SPA with one open chamber where the two o2 Sensors are. I saw HPA has a dual chamber manifold for the two sensors. But If we run that then what are we supposed to do with software. Why the **** are company's selling manifolds single and dual chamber. Why are company's selling this crap if there isn't an answer everybody knows. It should not be on the market to sell if there is no answer to make this run properly. This forum should not even exist with this problem it is not up to the consumer to buy something and then be left with trial and error work to get there car running right with a product someone puts out. Am I wrong?
#44
Beyond confused. I have ran 2 sensors in an eip ram horn and now a pag mani and have had 0 problems. 2 different cars.
WunderWagens June 10,2012 in Gilbert, PA... 2nd year http://www.wunderwagens-show.com
UnitedMotorsport r32 cam flash... get one
My Turbo .:R Build Thread
WunderWagens Vortex Forum
WunderWagens Facebook
#45
Don't know the answer to this. My car is at HPA right now to find out why, after the turbo install, the B1 sensor periodically just stops working. I asked Marcel about the issue of having the two 02 sensors in the exhaust manifold and he says there is no issue, after 10 years of building kits with this configuration it's proven and is the only way to reliably monitor and regulate the fueling between the hot and cold side (I have to assume this makes sense because I have not seen folks complaining about it or heard of 02 related issues with the HGP kits in Europe that run this config). Marcel says my car is the first he's run across with the symptoms I am having. At this point I have to take his word for it as there doesn't appear to be another option other than re-engineer my FT400 kit myself using different parts and I hate to do that.
Last edited by Arizman3; 10-05-2012 at 09:50 PM.
#46
jason from streetwerke used to poke fun of the o2 location, saying they are to close to the line
of fire on the ex mani, and i am pretty sure youre not the only one with o2 issues.
is it the tune?
is it a bad injector???
is it bad o2 sensor location? then why only one bank?
maybe something is happening in that bank that you should look deeper into.
bad wiring or contact lost? where? trace all the way to the ECM.
Last edited by ThatVdub; 10-05-2012 at 10:47 PM.
#47
#48
From my experience with VAG wiring.
Wires (metal and sheath) go bad VERY easily. Mainly why I got rid of all my MK4's recently.
Female pins tend to widen, and may need to be tightened or replaced.
Continuity is great to find the line, but when you find it, mess with it all its length (bend, tug, pull, etc), to see if there is a bad contact, break or short.
#49
Jason's design is very similar to the HPA manifold. Two O2 sensors on the exhaust manifold. There were some issues with the O2's being too close to each other and 'fighting' since it's not a divided mani.
I am interested in this though, as I'm looking to move to a single-bank tune with post turbo O2's myself....
UNITEDMOTORSPORT Authorized Dealer: Dallas/Ft Worth area!
#50
I was just reading a PDF from Bosch about their wide band 02 sensors. The article states that the operating environment, for exhaust gasses, the maximum permissible temperature is 1030C or 1886 F . I wonder what sort of exhaust gas temps at the exhaust ports are averaging in a tubo application. Anyone have any idea?
#52
#53
I know in diesel application 1,625 deg F is when **** starts melting. I know two different critters, BUT metals are the same. if your getting that hot then something needs to change.. hitting those temps momentarily is OK, but maintaining them is when siht goes south real fast. you can cryogenic freeze certain components and that helps to keep it from melting.
#54
#55
2008 R32 | UM Software | C2/Custom Stage 5 | Jeff Atwood Approved
Vortex Thread | GolfMk5 Thread | Old Video | Old Video Compilation | IUM | I
Performance Leds
#56
#57
Interesting, thanks for this information.
Curious as to where your temperature probe is placed. I've read that post turbo, temps typically drop approximately 200 F.
If it's in the exhaust manifold, if your temps are typical, this means that, in general, barring some issue that causes temps to increase significantly higher than what you are experiencing, our wideband o2 sensors, placed in the exhaust manifold are not subjected to temperatures that are outside the design envelope which Bosh says it a little over 1,800 F
#58
#59
As I have always said the HPA and similar design manifold have the lambda's far to close to the point of ignition facing the flame front from the exhaust ports....also the tuning needs to be looked at for sure and should be a bespoke tune NOT a standard map from other cars....every VW MK4 R32 Turbo is different even if they run the same kit.
MK4 R36 x Precision 6776 Turbo = Large Grin
#60
Well it is what it is with my kit, HPA and HGP may indeed have crafted a design placing the lambda sensors in an inconvenient place, you'd think that these two companies would have realized their mistake and rectified it by now, the design has been around a long time. So I am stuck with the design for now.
What I am wondering now is how I go about getting a bespoke tune for my car? Wouldn't a tuner, knowing that I have lambda sensors that are far too close to the flame front, just scoff at attempting to do a bespoke tune?
#62
I "ruined" a limited edition .:Race car
R32 Turbo Build Round 2! Faster, Lower, Smoother.
Integrated Engineering
#63
#64
I have been trying not to post in this thread because I know that the 'this manifold has the 02s too close to the exhaust port' theory is popular here. Im also understanding of the fact that there are other talented tuners, with different ways of doing things, and Im not trying to hate on them either.
Also, Ill probably get flamed for being biased, however, on the flip side I think some equal consideration should be given to who is actually behind the design of the HGP manifold before everyone rushes off with a definitive conclusion in their head about the 'problem/solution'.
This manifold wasnt just thrown together and thereafter 'oh, hey, lets just drill some holes somewhere/anywhere for the o2s'. Its purposely designed to be that way, by people who do have the knowledge and experience.
The owner of HGP is formerly of VW Scientific Engineering Research & Development.
He is very well respected amongst the serious german tuning industry, and continues an association with VW, as well as TechArt, MTM & others.
HGP are well known for their conservative and reliable reputation (my car is on standard 10,000 service intervals).
There are many many cars in existence after more than 20 years of operation.
HGP has, by far, way more experience turbo tuning the VR6 than anyone else in the world.
I think it would be an error of judgement to not consider these realities when looking for answers to various issues/problems.
It would be my suggestion that it is more likely for other parameters to be causing o2 problems than for the cause to be an exhaust manifold that has a proper design pedigree, and has been proven over more than a decade with hundreds and hundreds of cars...
That is just my logic. Yours may differ.
![]()
Last edited by jmh2002; 10-08-2012 at 04:39 PM.
HGP-T 450PS, Unibrace, 225/40/18 AD08s, OZ Ultraleggera, Light BBK F&R, Recaro Interior, .:R extras, MFD Navi, Phatbox, JCaps, Neuspeed, PSS9s, H2Sport Stage 3, DLI-Teknik, GC links, bHPP, etc...
#65
HPA fan boy....we didnt need the history lesson.....
its a fact that the lambda's are to close and will get damaged with the heat so close to the exhaust ports....hence the VW oem manifolds/collectors do not have lambdas in they are further down the down pipes away from the initial shock and heat.
MK4 R36 x Precision 6776 Turbo = Large Grin
#66
585 flywheel bhp HPA blackjack turbo conversion. Forged engine,ported head,+1mm Ferrea valves + spring,Schrick 268/264 cams,Vibratechnic engine mounts + dogbone,DRP gearbox,Clutchmaster FX850,Quaife up front and Peloquin in the rear etc etc.
DRP gearbox`s and R32 rear diffs always for sale
#69
ChrisJGuzman
Black 90 Corrado/Velocity Sport Tuning 2008cc now http://www.torque-factory.com
DBP 04 R32/Streetwerke GT540 on 100 octane
#70
Are you going to move both of them to the downpipe or just one? Are both required when you move them or does the tune you use only interrogate one of them? Is there a specified or optimum distance from the turbo or will anywhere suffice (4 to 6 inches is best)?
Also, I assume that if I do this, my HPA software will not function properly and I will have to find someone that can provide me with a "bespoke" tune and I also assume that a bespoke tune requires the tuner have the car in his/her hands to do it?
Last edited by Arizman3; 10-08-2012 at 10:08 PM.