VWVortex


+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 18 of 18

Thread: Wastegate door not closing all the way..(?) how can I be certain?

  1. 10-03-2012 10:51 AM #1
    I bypassed my TruBoost and put the n75 back in. Now, the boost doesn't build as quickly but it boosts HARD and has lots of power. But it's building so slow at low revs, that it almos feels like the WG door isn't staying closed to help me build boost. Is there anyway I can test to see if its closing all the way?
    04 225QC Black/F23/IE Rods/Gonzo StageIII/E85/Bosch EV14 750cc/LiquidTT/Podi/AEM dry flow/Forge WG/MadMAxDV/Forge hoses/Treadstone TR8/42 Catch can/42 DP/Magnaflow Cat back/Eibach coilovers/Neuspeed RSB /KMAC/Defcons & poly/25mm & 17mm/RS4 Reps/ Brembo Calipers/ Zimmerman rotors/Hawk pads/Braided lines/B&M shifter/Votex body/Suede/Carbon/shaved..

  2. Member Chickenman35's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 28th, 2006
    Location
    West Coast, Canada
    Posts
    2,078
    Vehicles
    Varied and lots
    10-03-2012 10:57 AM #2


    "...I recommend books. People who don't know what they're talking about are less likely to write a book about the subject...."

  3. Member Chickenman35's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 28th, 2006
    Location
    West Coast, Canada
    Posts
    2,078
    Vehicles
    Varied and lots
    10-03-2012 11:04 AM #3
    Seriously...I don't know if there's any way to be sure other than removing the turbo and checking it out. There's just so bloody little room in there to check things properly.

    I'm going through the same issue myself. I'm suspecting that my linkage is either binding or not closing all the way, as I lose way too much boost as the revs climb. No boost leaks ( pressure checked ) and Turbo is in good shape ( minimal shaft play ).
    "...I recommend books. People who don't know what they're talking about are less likely to write a book about the subject...."

  4. 10-03-2012 01:43 PM #4
    Quote Originally Posted by Chickenman35 View Post
    Seriously...I don't know if there's any way to be sure other than removing the turbo and checking it out. There's just so bloody little room in there to check things properly.

    I'm going through the same issue myself. I'm suspecting that my linkage is either binding or not closing all the way, as I lose way too much boost as the revs climb. No boost leaks ( pressure checked ) and Turbo is in good shape ( minimal shaft play ).
    In the 225 TT, there is enough room (ask me how I know). Eric just need to unclip the rod to the flapper arm, and rotate the gate back and forth to ensure proper movement and feel a positive stop when the gate closes down. Then, with the gate locked fully closed, clip the actuator rod back in and add 1-2 mm of actuator preload.

    Eric, if the changes are only felt when using the N75, this leads me to believe that the culprit is the N75 duty cycle. If the EBC can control the onset to your liking, so can the N75 (maybe not to the same accuracy), as long as the proper duty cycle is preset in the ECU. It is very common for tuners to set weak "cover my ass" N75 duty or "rod friendly" as they like to spin it. If this is the case with you, there isn't much you can do, except bypass or run your EBC in tandem with the N75 to get the boost onset you're looking for.

  5. Member forcefedjetta's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 14th, 2003
    Location
    metrowest
    Posts
    1,298
    Vehicles
    02 jetta 1.8t
    10-03-2012 04:16 PM #5
    I had a problem like this where the boost was slow to build long story short my ghl dp flex joint collapsed on the inside leaving a quarter sized hole for the exhaust to go through.



    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
    i wish my grass was emo so it would cut it's self

  6. Member GLI-R's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 1st, 2011
    Location
    Puebla, Pue. Mexico
    Posts
    464
    Vehicles
    Rolling Thunder
    10-03-2012 04:47 PM #6
    My car is an stage 2+ 1.8t and im experiencing problems (stock k03)

    normally it hits 24psi and hols from 20 to 16 at redline

    yesterday out of nowhere it started to have way more lag, now it barely reaches 18 psi and can only hold 9-10 at redline

    It does not have any leaks, the turbo just spools way slower

    i dont know whats going on, i have been asking and researching and i ended up here

    would this be the n75 valve not opening the wastegate? N75 Failing? o_O

    WTF
    -2011 MK4.5 1.8T VW Motorsport GLI R Proyect. Codename ".:Rolling Thunder"

    -"The ammount of Love, Money and HorsePower We Can Have Is Never Enough" -Sensei Mawy Luna

  7. 10-03-2012 10:12 PM #7
    Yeah, the N75 DOES NOT like the F23. I'll be interested in how Gonzo plans to tune with it.
    04 225QC Black/F23/IE Rods/Gonzo StageIII/E85/Bosch EV14 750cc/LiquidTT/Podi/AEM dry flow/Forge WG/MadMAxDV/Forge hoses/Treadstone TR8/42 Catch can/42 DP/Magnaflow Cat back/Eibach coilovers/Neuspeed RSB /KMAC/Defcons & poly/25mm & 17mm/RS4 Reps/ Brembo Calipers/ Zimmerman rotors/Hawk pads/Braided lines/B&M shifter/Votex body/Suede/Carbon/shaved..

  8. 10-04-2012 02:25 PM #8
    So I ran the WG line straight to the boost source. If I hold steady throttle, it bounces around from 8, 9, 10psi. It's super erratic. I'm thinking that my new WG isn't holding boost.
    04 225QC Black/F23/IE Rods/Gonzo StageIII/E85/Bosch EV14 750cc/LiquidTT/Podi/AEM dry flow/Forge WG/MadMAxDV/Forge hoses/Treadstone TR8/42 Catch can/42 DP/Magnaflow Cat back/Eibach coilovers/Neuspeed RSB /KMAC/Defcons & poly/25mm & 17mm/RS4 Reps/ Brembo Calipers/ Zimmerman rotors/Hawk pads/Braided lines/B&M shifter/Votex body/Suede/Carbon/shaved..

  9. 10-04-2012 03:13 PM #9
    Quote Originally Posted by warranty225cpe View Post
    So I ran the WG line straight to the boost source. If I hold steady throttle, it bounces around from 8, 9, 10psi. It's super erratic. I'm thinking that my new WG isn't holding boost.
    I don't think this is terribly abnormal! Generated positive pressure acting on the actuator, as well exhaust gases acting against the wastegate flap are not static and very dependent on load, rpm, and a dynamic VE.

    A perfect static pressure as a result of this test would mean that you can keep everything in steady state, which I doubt you can without some specific load bearing dyno.

    Edit
    You also seem to confuse the wastegate which is an internal part of the turbo and the actuator that is an external device in charge of regulating exhaust bypass. Saying your new wastegate isn't holding boost would mean a faulty gate that isn't operating properly (a turbo issue). The variable in your case is the actuator (external to the turbo and wastegate), if you could take a video of how erratic the pressure generated by the test is, it would help assess if their is an issue or not.
    Last edited by Marcus_Aurelius; 10-04-2012 at 03:23 PM.

  10. 10-04-2012 03:48 PM #10
    Quote Originally Posted by Marcus_Aurelius View Post
    I don't think this is terribly abnormal! Generated positive pressure acting on the actuator, as well exhaust gases acting against the wastegate flap are not static and very dependent on load, rpm, and a dynamic VE.

    A perfect static pressure as a result of this test would mean that you can keep everything in steady state, which I doubt you can without some specific load bearing dyno.

    Edit
    You also seem to confuse the wastegate which is an internal part of the turbo and the actuator that is an external device in charge of regulating exhaust bypass. Saying your new wastegate isn't holding boost would mean a faulty gate that isn't operating properly (a turbo issue). The variable in your case is the actuator (external to the turbo and wastegate), if you could take a video of how erratic the pressure generated by the test is, it would help assess if their is an issue or not.
    Yes, wastegate internal and actuator external. Got that. But I'm referring to the leaking (or failure to pressurize). Not sure if its the diaphragm in the actuator or WG flapper door causing the problems.
    04 225QC Black/F23/IE Rods/Gonzo StageIII/E85/Bosch EV14 750cc/LiquidTT/Podi/AEM dry flow/Forge WG/MadMAxDV/Forge hoses/Treadstone TR8/42 Catch can/42 DP/Magnaflow Cat back/Eibach coilovers/Neuspeed RSB /KMAC/Defcons & poly/25mm & 17mm/RS4 Reps/ Brembo Calipers/ Zimmerman rotors/Hawk pads/Braided lines/B&M shifter/Votex body/Suede/Carbon/shaved..

  11. Moderator groggory's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 21st, 2003
    Location
    Long Beach, CA
    Posts
    9,732
    Vehicles
    2002 VW GTI 1.8 BT
    10-04-2012 04:03 PM #11
    Quote Originally Posted by warranty225cpe View Post
    Yes, wastegate internal and actuator external. Got that. But I'm referring to the leaking (or failure to pressurize). Not sure if its the diaphragm in the actuator or WG flapper door causing the problems.
    If I were you I'd just hook my wastegate up to a bike pump and slowly pressure it to check for when it begins to open.
    My Build
    My FAQ / DIY Thread -- Look here for 90% of the questions you have
    FS: New in box, primer'd 20AE body kit (front+rear valences and side skirts) -- PM me for details
    FS: Fiberglass 20AE replica spoiler. No scratches. Reflex Silver.

  12. 10-04-2012 04:27 PM #12
    Quote Originally Posted by groggory View Post
    If I were you I'd just hook my wastegate up to a bike pump and slowly pressure it to check for when it begins to open.
    i use a compressor. Even with preload on it, it moves with a very low amount of pressure. I had it starting to move at about 4-5psi. but with the same amount of preload Im seeing between 8-10psi. Im really starting to think that my brand new actuator has some problems.
    04 225QC Black/F23/IE Rods/Gonzo StageIII/E85/Bosch EV14 750cc/LiquidTT/Podi/AEM dry flow/Forge WG/MadMAxDV/Forge hoses/Treadstone TR8/42 Catch can/42 DP/Magnaflow Cat back/Eibach coilovers/Neuspeed RSB /KMAC/Defcons & poly/25mm & 17mm/RS4 Reps/ Brembo Calipers/ Zimmerman rotors/Hawk pads/Braided lines/B&M shifter/Votex body/Suede/Carbon/shaved..

  13. Member RodgertheRabit II's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 13th, 2012
    Location
    North Carolina
    Posts
    455
    Vehicles
    JB 20th
    10-04-2012 04:36 PM #13
    Im pretty sure the problem is the Forge WG you are using isnt designed to withstand the F23. I remember someone else had an issue running a ForgeWG on a FT. Doug even tried some aftermarket ones but did not have much success with them.

    Not sure if you requested a specific spring or not but this is right off of their site...

    "This product is built with a predetermined actuator spring suitable for at, or slightly above factory boost levels. The actuator can be assembled with a stiffer spring upon request. Please contact us directly concerning this process
    It is designed and built with the intention of increasing the boost output of a turbocharged system. We cannot guarantee compatibility with all applications, nor the ability to increase the boost output beyond a level that is within the parameters set by the engine-management-system of the given vehicle at the time of installation, whether that system is factory or aftermarket."

  14. 10-04-2012 04:38 PM #14
    I Should have mentioned, I have the stock at FT wastegate in now.
    04 225QC Black/F23/IE Rods/Gonzo StageIII/E85/Bosch EV14 750cc/LiquidTT/Podi/AEM dry flow/Forge WG/MadMAxDV/Forge hoses/Treadstone TR8/42 Catch can/42 DP/Magnaflow Cat back/Eibach coilovers/Neuspeed RSB /KMAC/Defcons & poly/25mm & 17mm/RS4 Reps/ Brembo Calipers/ Zimmerman rotors/Hawk pads/Braided lines/B&M shifter/Votex body/Suede/Carbon/shaved..

  15. Former Advertiser
    Join Date
    Jul 20th, 2011
    Posts
    1,529
    Vehicles
    99.5 Jetta TDI, 02 GTI VR6, 00 Golf 1.8T, 01 Jetta Wolfsburg 1.8T, 00 Jetta TDI
    10-04-2012 05:15 PM #15
    Call me and let's chat about this so I can walk you thru some things.

  16. 10-04-2012 05:15 PM #16
    Quote Originally Posted by Gonzo@GonzoTuning View Post
    Call me and let's chat about this so I can walk you thru some things.
    Calling you now
    04 225QC Black/F23/IE Rods/Gonzo StageIII/E85/Bosch EV14 750cc/LiquidTT/Podi/AEM dry flow/Forge WG/MadMAxDV/Forge hoses/Treadstone TR8/42 Catch can/42 DP/Magnaflow Cat back/Eibach coilovers/Neuspeed RSB /KMAC/Defcons & poly/25mm & 17mm/RS4 Reps/ Brembo Calipers/ Zimmerman rotors/Hawk pads/Braided lines/B&M shifter/Votex body/Suede/Carbon/shaved..

  17. Former Advertiser
    Join Date
    Jul 20th, 2011
    Posts
    1,529
    Vehicles
    99.5 Jetta TDI, 02 GTI VR6, 00 Golf 1.8T, 01 Jetta Wolfsburg 1.8T, 00 Jetta TDI
    10-04-2012 06:09 PM #17
    Quote Originally Posted by RodgertheRabit II View Post
    "This product is built with a predetermined actuator spring suitable for at, or slightly above factory boost levels. The actuator can be assembled with a stiffer spring upon request. Please contact us directly concerning this process
    It is designed and built with the intention of increasing the boost output of a turbocharged system. We cannot guarantee compatibility with all applications, nor the ability to increase the boost output beyond a level that is within the parameters set by the engine-management-system of the given vehicle at the time of installation, whether that system is factory or aftermarket."
    Highlighted the important info.
    Quote Originally Posted by warranty225cpe View Post
    Calling you now

    Let me know what you come up with.

  18. 10-05-2012 09:20 AM #18
    Quote Originally Posted by Gonzo@GonzoTuning View Post

    Let me know what you come up with.
    Turns out my problem is a crappy wastegate. I'm going back to the FORGE. Just not looking forward to doing the R & R again. I bet I can get it done in under an hour now
    04 225QC Black/F23/IE Rods/Gonzo StageIII/E85/Bosch EV14 750cc/LiquidTT/Podi/AEM dry flow/Forge WG/MadMAxDV/Forge hoses/Treadstone TR8/42 Catch can/42 DP/Magnaflow Cat back/Eibach coilovers/Neuspeed RSB /KMAC/Defcons & poly/25mm & 17mm/RS4 Reps/ Brembo Calipers/ Zimmerman rotors/Hawk pads/Braided lines/B&M shifter/Votex body/Suede/Carbon/shaved..

+ Reply to Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts