why does it have to be air? why can't it be a timing issue? check the output of your cam position sensor (assuming it's coilpack of course) also check for vacuum leaks...everywhere![]()
#1
Hi everybody!
My problem is simple:
The air flow measured by the MAF suddenly drops for a second or two and eventually makes the engine die.
The MAF is not faulty (replaced with a new one and readings are consistent with the engine behavior).
The throttle body is not faulty (replaced with another one and position readings are consistent with engine behavior).
Thus, what is before the MAF and could make the airflow suddenly drop? Filter is clean.
#2
why does it have to be air? why can't it be a timing issue? check the output of your cam position sensor (assuming it's coilpack of course) also check for vacuum leaks...everywhere![]()
#3
I assumed it was air flow because of the MAF readings:
when the engine is going to stall, the mass airflow measured by the MAF sensor is lower than it should be (car's idling). As a result the engine "load" increases (basically the throttle opens more), but if the airflow "drop" shown by the MAF is too significant, the throttle opening is not sufficient (fast enough?) to compensate for it.
I don't have the readings saved on this computer, but I will try to post that tomorrow.
I have not paid attention to the timings, so I'll look into that. Overall I keep ending with a supposed vacuum leak... what's the best way to look for it? Soap and pressured lines?
#4
When the engine is stalling, air flow readings will be lower....
As far as finding vacuum leaks... old school trick is spraying electrical component cleaner or something pretty flammable and spraying it on the hoses. When RPM comes up a good amount, you found the leak.
2002.5 Jetta 1.8T - TOTALED (dodging deer)
2002.5 24v GTI - TOTALED (rear-ended by a Jeep)
1992 Corrado SLC - The toy & DD
2012 Golf R - The weekender
#5
The thing is that the air flow gets lower BEFORE the engine RPM starts dropping. See the readings below:
First event, car is parked, I am not touching/doing anything but recording
Same recording, a few seconds later, still not interacting with the car:Code:Time [s] RPM Engine load [%] Injector Period [ms] Air flow [g/s] 7.88 640 18 2.87 3.75 --> idle 8.28 640 18 3.28 3.64 --> idle 8.68 680 15.8 2.46 1.31 --> idle, air flow drops badly 9.08 440 20.3 4.51 9.33 --> RPM drops, car responds by opening the throttle... 9.48 600 28.6 4.92 3.58 --> which saves the car from stalling 9.88 720 23.3 4.1 3.64 --> RPM keeps going up for about a second (lag) 10.28 800 18 3.28 2.81 --> RPM keeps going up for about a second (lag)
Basically this recording shows that the air flow drops first, and in some cases, even opening the throttle wider is not sufficient to save the engine from stalling (yes, I am sure 100% the throttle is working fine).Code:Time [s] RPM Engine load [%] Injector Period [ms] Air flow [g/s] 21.87 680 15.8 3.28 3.28 --> idle 22.28 680 14.3 2.46 2.22 --> idle, low air flow 22.78 560 14.3 3.28 3.31 --> RPM drops 23.18 440 20.3 4.1 5.25 --> RPM keep dropping a bit, but throttle opened and air flow increased 23.69 560 22.6 4.51 2.86 --> RPM going back up, but air flow is still too low despite wider open throttle 24.09 600 21.1 4.1 3.08 24.57 600 21.1 4.1 4.22 24.99 440 23.3 4.92 4.72 --> Why does it drop? Is that due to the high injector period? 25.48 400 30.1 8.61 3.5 --> same question? 25.88 920 36.8 6.97 1.44 --> pretty bad airflow despite throttle significantly opened, RPM is going up as a result of the larger air flow 1 sec earlier 26.28 1120 17.3 3.28 1.78 --> same remark 26.78 680 13.5 2.87 2.61 --> the airflow has been too low for too long, engine is dying 27.18 320 17.3 4.1 5.22 --> there we go 27.58 80 34.6 0.41 0 --> :facepalm: 27.98 0 34.6 0.41 0 --> :facepalm: :banghead: :mad:
I guess I'll go look for the vacuum leak. Anybody has a scheme of where the vacuum lines are running?