Username or Email Address
Do you already have an account?
Forgot your password?
  • Log in or Sign up

    VWVortex


    The Car Lounge
    Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
    Results 1 to 25 of 36

    Thread: Example of how useless Carfax and used car dealers are

    1. Member 2000JettaGLXVR6's Avatar
      Join Date
      Oct 17th, 2002
      Location
      Southern California
      Posts
      9,562
      Vehicles
      2015 e-Golf, 2007 Subaru Outback
      10-27-2012 04:12 PM #1
      You may recall I purchased a B6 S4 a few months ago — long story short, it burned over 9 quarts of oil in 3,000 miles and ended up having a bad engine, so BMW of San Diego purchased it back from me minus $1,000 in expenses. I was curious what they did with the car, so I pulled up the Carfax to see. They ended up selling it at auction...



      Not to worry says the Car Fox: "Millions of used vehicles are bought and sold at auction every year."

      So I google the VIN and find that the car was now at some shady used car lot (it's been sold too, this is from Google Cache)...



      "Mint condition Runs and looks great RECARO seats Must see it hard to find model Call before its sold!!!!!!"

      Carfax: Useless
      Used Car Dealers: Shady

      Here's the VIN in case the new owner stumbles upon this page: WAUPL68E44A220313
      Last edited by 2000JettaGLXVR6; 10-28-2012 at 03:03 PM.

    2. Member markus037's Avatar
      Join Date
      Nov 14th, 2011
      Location
      West Chester, PA
      Posts
      462
      Vehicles
      00 CB M5
      10-27-2012 04:23 PM #2
      not all used car places are shady but you can tell if they are good or bad just by the ad and what other types of cars they have on the lot as well as where the lot is located.


      but i hate carfax as well. i bought my car and had accident history on it but I inspected it myself before buying and nothing ever looked like it was ever involved in an accident, no frame damage, overspray or mis-aligned panels but the PO had the front bumper replaced and I guess turned it into his insurance. For all I know he could have had a cracked bumper and just had his insurance pay for it.

      needless to say i think these car dealers should stop worrying about carfax so much and actually look at the physical and mechanical condition of the cars they sell.

    3. Member a2a4raddo's Avatar
      Join Date
      Aug 14th, 2001
      Location
      New York
      Posts
      19,818
      Vehicles
      Porsche & Honda
      10-27-2012 04:28 PM #3
      Its not just the dealer, but the customer as well. Just about everyone who looks at a used car on a dealers lot asks for a car fax nowadays. If the carfax is dirty, makes it harder to sell the car and also devalues it as a retail piece as well as a trade in.

      Carfax is not 100 percent. The car you bought had a dirty carfax but no signs of damage. On the flip side, my buddy's car has had a fender and hood replaced and half the car has been repainted, car fax is clean however.

      I always ask to see both a carfax as well as an auto check. But I still go over the entire car as well.

    4. Member nm+'s Avatar
      Join Date
      Jan 6th, 2006
      Location
      Land of Bro-Dozer Ya Yas
      Posts
      19,739
      Vehicles
      2005 Legacy GT Wagon 5MT w/overnight diffs from Japan; 2013 Mazda 2 5MT
      10-27-2012 04:35 PM #4
      This is why people should always get a PPI with a leakdown on used cars.
      That said, if you posted the vin in plain text it would become googleable.

      Also, short ownership periods like that should raise a massive red flag. You ca also report to carfax yourself.
      Last edited by nm+; 10-27-2012 at 04:38 PM.
      Quote Originally Posted by Ducky TSX
      The Car Lounge likes to compare apples to llamas

    5. Member markus037's Avatar
      Join Date
      Nov 14th, 2011
      Location
      West Chester, PA
      Posts
      462
      Vehicles
      00 CB M5
      10-27-2012 04:36 PM #5
      Quote Originally Posted by a2a4raddo View Post
      Its not just the dealer, but the customer as well. Just about everyone who looks at a used car on a dealers lot asks for a car fax nowadays. If the carfax is dirty, makes it harder to sell the car and also devalues it as a retail piece as well as a trade in.

      Carfax is not 100 percent. The car you bought had a dirty carfax but no signs of damage. On the flip side, my buddy's car has had a fender and hood replaced and half the car has been repainted, car fax is clean however.

      I always ask to see both a carfax as well as an auto check. But I still go over the entire car as well.
      totally agree. i always go over any car im interested inside and out. you can usually tell if the car has been maintained just by looking at it.

      i went to look at a 330i ZHP a few weeks back that was located on some used car lot that was a total POS.The drivers window didnt work properly, coolant light on, bubble on right rear tire, dents and scratches all over it and the rear seat looked like a dog had ran back and forth on it quite often and the kicker was the kidney grille fell out after closing the hood. After pointing the defects out to the salesman he acted like i insulted him and just said "well if its not the car for you then it isnt the car for you" he was then going to have his "mechanic" look at it.

    6. 10-27-2012 04:38 PM #6
      Hell with Carfax, autocheck and the like. If I know a car has been to auction, I'll generally avoid it. There are not a lot of good reasons for a car to end up at an auction, and the invariable loss of documentation and accessories keeps my money away even if one might be good.
      call it potatography

    7. Member nm+'s Avatar
      Join Date
      Jan 6th, 2006
      Location
      Land of Bro-Dozer Ya Yas
      Posts
      19,739
      Vehicles
      2005 Legacy GT Wagon 5MT w/overnight diffs from Japan; 2013 Mazda 2 5MT
      10-27-2012 04:39 PM #7
      Quote Originally Posted by turbo_nine View Post
      Hell with Carfax, autocheck and the like. If I know a car has been to auction, I'll generally avoid it. There are not a lot of good reasons for a car to end up at an auction, and the invariable loss of documentation and accessories keeps my money away even if one might be good.
      How the hell do you find a modern used car that isn't sold private party that wasn't an auction vehicle at one time?
      Quote Originally Posted by Ducky TSX
      The Car Lounge likes to compare apples to llamas

    8. 10-27-2012 04:47 PM #8
      Quote Originally Posted by nm+ View Post
      How the hell do you find a modern used car that isn't sold private party that wasn't an auction vehicle at one time?
      You answered your own question.
      call it potatography

    9. Banned
      Join Date
      Mar 8th, 2011
      Location
      Bellevue Hospital Center
      Posts
      8,728
      10-27-2012 04:49 PM #9
      Carfax only works if the previous owners care enough to update it frequently and accurately.

      ITT: people think Carfax is updated religiously

    10. Member nm+'s Avatar
      Join Date
      Jan 6th, 2006
      Location
      Land of Bro-Dozer Ya Yas
      Posts
      19,739
      Vehicles
      2005 Legacy GT Wagon 5MT w/overnight diffs from Japan; 2013 Mazda 2 5MT
      10-27-2012 04:52 PM #10
      Quote Originally Posted by turbo_nine View Post
      You answered your own question.
      I guess if you limit yourself to 1 owner private party vehicles, that is possible.

      My car is an auction car and came with all the receipts.
      Quote Originally Posted by Ducky TSX
      The Car Lounge likes to compare apples to llamas

    11. Member oh noes! cars!'s Avatar
      Join Date
      Apr 24th, 2007
      Location
      Toronto
      Posts
      6,267
      Vehicles
      '07 Mazda 3s GT, '13 Subaru Impreza Sport, KHS Flite 100
      10-27-2012 04:54 PM #11
      Also why is it shady if another dealer buys it from auction and the BMW dealer auctions an old Audi they fixed? (they did fix it, no?) It's just one of a billion used auto transactions that happen daily it's not like the new dealer read your thread and said "**** it we'll take a chance"...

      Ignorance is bliss
      Quote Originally Posted by MK420TH92 View Post
      Now b/c of this im fkn paranoid about mines. For for theifs out there u better watch out... cuz im nockturnal....i dont go to sleep till 4am either.... and i bought a machette a ago... if i see u near my car im running out there and ima chop ur ass up.... real shiitt
      http://www.adventureseekers.co
      We are giants, with stars at our fingertips

    12. 10-27-2012 04:56 PM #12
      Quote Originally Posted by C4 A6 View Post
      Carfax only works if the previous owners care enough to update it frequently and accurately.

      ITT: people think Carfax is updated religiously
      ITT: People beginning to realize that Carfax is filled with false negatives.
      call it potatography

    13. Member nm+'s Avatar
      Join Date
      Jan 6th, 2006
      Location
      Land of Bro-Dozer Ya Yas
      Posts
      19,739
      Vehicles
      2005 Legacy GT Wagon 5MT w/overnight diffs from Japan; 2013 Mazda 2 5MT
      10-27-2012 04:56 PM #13
      Quote Originally Posted by oh noes! cars! View Post
      Also why is it shady if another dealer buys it from auction and the BMW dealer auctions an old Audi they fixed? (they did fix it, no?)
      I think the implication is that they didn't fix it.
      Quote Originally Posted by Ducky TSX
      The Car Lounge likes to compare apples to llamas

    14. 10-27-2012 04:57 PM #14
      Quote Originally Posted by nm+ View Post
      My car is an auction car and came with all the receipts.
      That's terribly unusual, but it would reassure me enough to make the same purchase.
      call it potatography

    15. Member dopaz's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jun 17th, 2002
      Location
      Mechanicsburg, PA
      Posts
      964
      Vehicles
      [Current:] 99 Civic [Past:] 84 Rabbit, 85 Quantum, 87 Jetta, 97 Jetta, 96 Passat
      10-27-2012 04:57 PM #15
      Quote Originally Posted by markus037 View Post
      needless to say i think these car dealers should stop worrying about carfax so much and actually look at the physical and mechanical condition of the cars they sell.
      Quote Originally Posted by a2a4raddo View Post
      Its not just the dealer, but the customer as well. Just about everyone who looks at a used car on a dealers lot asks for a car fax nowadays.
      This is the problem. CarFax has done an excellent job with their marketing. They blasted consumers with the cute "Car Fox" b.s. and now car shoppers *demand* a CarFax. Dealers are now pretty much forced to provide this information due to customer demand, and in turn must pay CarFax a fee for doing so. This happens despite the fact that a clean CarFax report does not guarantee a clean vehicle, *and* a dirty CarFax report does not guarantee a problematic vehicle. For me, these facts make the report damn near useless.

      Quote Originally Posted by a2a4raddo View Post
      Carfax is not 100 percent. The car you bought had a dirty carfax but no signs of damage. On the flip side, my buddy's car has had a fender and hood replaced and half the car has been repainted, car fax is clean however. I always ask to see both a carfax as well as an auto check. But I still go over the entire car as well.
      So, you recognize that the data on a CarFax report cannot be trusted, yet you demand it anyways?

      Quote Originally Posted by nm+ View Post
      This is why people should always get a PPI with a leakdown on used cars.
      Good advice. If you cannot thoroughly evaluate a vehicle on your own, find a trusted 3rd party to inspect it prior to purchase. You certainly can't rely on the selling party to provide impartial, accurate, and unbiased information about a vehicle they must sell to remain in business. CarFax is not the proper 3rd party to rely on either, tracking paperwork changes on titles and "Were there any insurance claims (Yes / No)" is such an incomplete assessment of a vehicle that it is almost completely worthless.

    16. Banned
      Join Date
      Mar 8th, 2011
      Location
      Bellevue Hospital Center
      Posts
      8,728
      10-27-2012 04:59 PM #16
      Quote Originally Posted by dopaz View Post
      So, you recognize that the data on a CarFax report cannot be trusted, yet you demand it anyways?
      Accuracy all depends on the owner who is updating it. Sure, there are scumbags who will lie, but more often than not the carfax is pretty accurate.

    17. 10-27-2012 05:00 PM #17
      Would carfax have even had any report on it ? No accident's, documentation of reg and some title changes what else should it say though ? Have you ever seen it say something like burns oil? smells like cigarettes or burrito farts ? Carfax seems to now have a ton more detail regarding dealer services wheres before it was very basic.

      I looked at a 2006 Wrangler Rubicon in stunning condition earlier this year. The dealers autocheck report mentioned "vehicle serviced" at on point in its life. I ran carfax just for s&g's and just as I had my heart set on it and was about to sign. I noticed that carfax found that it had failed it's first smogcheck before it was tranferred from their other dealership. I walked away sadly... but I didn't want a vehicle that had issues.

    18. Geriatric Member VDub2625's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jan 3rd, 2003
      Location
      Fall River, MA
      Posts
      47,197
      Vehicles
      12 Golf 2.5, 90 Jetta GLI 16v, 99.5 Cabrio Highline, 92 Golf GL
      10-27-2012 05:01 PM #18
      I'm confused what the problem was? it had a broken engine, like millions of used cars have broken parts, it was sold back to the dealer and then at auction... who's to say someone didn't fix it? or that any one out there could buy a used car with broken parts? not all service records get entered.

      Was the car in an accident? No? Seems like Carfax did it's job (yes, I know there are ways of getting around that as well). it doesn't promise to inspect the car and that runs and drives just fine for you. That's up to a new buyer to do an inspection.

      CarFax is the kind of service that, if it comes up positive for a bad history, you know it has a bad history, but negative doesn't mean clean. It's a tool, not an end-all that most people seem to think it is.

    19. Member tharsis's Avatar
      Join Date
      Apr 8th, 2006
      Location
      by the beach bruh
      Posts
      1,694
      Vehicles
      mk3 putabasket, b5.5 wagon
      10-27-2012 05:01 PM #19
      There are a lot of decent cars sold at auction. Just because a car went to auction doesn't mean its ****ed up. Generally used cars have to float around somewhere, they don't just sit hundreds of used cars on each dealer lot every year...

      That being said, you can generally tell how well a car has been taken care of if you give it a good once over and consider the wear and tear vs whats expected for a car of that age and mileage

    20. 10-27-2012 05:04 PM #20
      Quote Originally Posted by C4 A6 View Post
      Accuracy all depends on the owner who is updating it. Sure, there are scumbags who will lie, but more often than not the carfax is pretty accurate.
      When the owner is the Insurance Company and they have no incentive to report because they're the ones who bought the car (as a collision, for instance) and are sending the car to auction to recoup their loss...

      Well, you can see how Carfax might be left out of the loop.
      call it potatography

    21. Banned
      Join Date
      Mar 6th, 2003
      Location
      Toronto
      Posts
      3,798
      10-27-2012 05:06 PM #21
      Carfax is useless indeed.
      Best thing to do is to get the body checked out by a reputable bodyshop,
      saying in writing that there are or arent any accidents on the car !

      If an accident is not reported, no Carfax will know !

    22. Member dopaz's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jun 17th, 2002
      Location
      Mechanicsburg, PA
      Posts
      964
      Vehicles
      [Current:] 99 Civic [Past:] 84 Rabbit, 85 Quantum, 87 Jetta, 97 Jetta, 96 Passat
      10-27-2012 05:17 PM #22
      Quote Originally Posted by C4 A6 View Post
      Accuracy all depends on the owner who is updating it. Sure, there are scumbags who will lie, but more often than not the carfax is pretty accurate.
      As a car owner, why would I report anything at all to CarFax? If I accurately report that there were problems, I've just shot myself in the foot and devalued the vehicle. If I report maintenance, etc I'm doing CarFax's work for them for no compensation. Why would I do that? Do you think a significant portion of car owners are performing this self-reporting?

      Quote Originally Posted by veedublvr View Post
      Carfax seems to now have a ton more detail regarding dealer services wheres before it was very basic.
      I once worked as a programmer for a dealership group. When our CarFax contract (we had an unlimited CarFax account and run reports on potential trade-ins and all retail used vehicles) came up for renewal CarFax forced us to begin sending all of our vehicle service records to them, or they would not renew our contract. The data they demanded basically consisted of VIN, Mileage, and Work Performed... for every car that went through any of the service departments under our corporate umbrella. Now that dealership still has to pad the price all of its used vehicles with the "CarFax tax" (that cost is going right to the consumer), and also share all of the service department business data with CarFax.

      The actions of CarFax primarily benefit CarFax. Their service is not very useful due to the gaping holes in the data, but through marketing they have car shoppers convinced it is a necessity. When you demand a CarFax you are increasing the cost of the used vehicle you are trying to buy without really knowing much more about it.

    23. Member a2a4raddo's Avatar
      Join Date
      Aug 14th, 2001
      Location
      New York
      Posts
      19,818
      Vehicles
      Porsche & Honda
      10-27-2012 05:48 PM #23
      Quote Originally Posted by dopaz View Post



      So, you recognize that the data on a CarFax report cannot be trusted, yet you demand it anyways? .
      Absolutely. Carfax data will tell me how many owner the vehicle has had, where it spent most of its life (florida car or New England car, etc). These are things I can use with carfax. But It is not 100 percent in that the carfax could be clean, while the vehicles has been involved in two accidents. Which is why I will look over the vehicle myself, as well as ask for a carfax and an autocheck. An accident that pops up on autocheck may not be on carfax and vice verse. I have seen this a few times. Lastly, if the carfax report comes back with 3 accidents on file, I don't want to purchase the car regardless of how clean it is.....even if there is zero paint work. That just tells me the trade in value will be crap and selling it privately will be difficult.

      So yes, I do recognize that carfax reports cannot be trusted 100 percent. They are just a guide. And yes, I demand both the carfax as well as the autocheck anyway.

    24. Member
      Join Date
      Jul 30th, 2006
      Posts
      584
      Vehicles
      2009 Outlander SE, 2008 Fit Sport
      10-27-2012 06:02 PM #24
      I recently traded in a Mark IV Jetta and took a look at the CarFax once the dealer put it up on AutoTrader. I had been rear-ended pretty badly a few years ago - The total damage was about $6000 and it took about 4 weeks to fix. In the CarFax, it said "vehicle serviced" and was reported as accident free.

      What needs to happen for it to make it to CarFax? There was a police report, insurance claim, etc.

    25. Member someguy123's Avatar
      Join Date
      Sep 30th, 2005
      Posts
      16,149
      Vehicles
      Lexus Hybrid, '15 Panda Smart
      10-27-2012 06:05 PM #25
      Quote Originally Posted by 2000JettaGLXVR6 View Post
      You may recall I purchased a B6 S4 a few months ago — long story short, it burned over 9 quarts of oil in 3,000 miles and ended up having a bad engine, so BMW of San Diego purchased it back from me minus $1,000 in expenses. I was curious what they did with the car, so I pulled up the Carfax to see. They ended up selling it at auction...
      I hope you learned your lesson.

    Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •