My Profile | Active Users | HELP | SEARCH | Google Search


  
sold on expense
Member



Offline

Member Since
3-21-2003
3401 posts

Iowa City IA
1988 VW "Michael J." Fox Wagon

 Starter spinning freely but not engaging« »

Howdy foxers....checked the search, seems like somebody had a similar problem to me but never got an answer. It just started doing this where I would turn the starter and it would whir up without resistance as if it weren't in contact with the flywheel. However, even if I move the car around to get the flywheel in a different orientation it will most of the time do the same thing, so maybe not teeth? Could this be a problem with the starter itself?

On that note, how is the best way to get to a starter on a Fox Wagon with A/C...I can't see it directly from the bay but I wasn't using a flashlight and the wires are nest-like at the moment...which side is it on? Seems like its going to be a bitch because of the engine mounting.

Thanks guys, hopefully somebody has experienced this before.



-Rupert Ellis-
DubbyDriver
Member



Offline

Member Since
10-23-2003
1228 posts

St. Paul MN
99.5 2.slow jetta(Bebe), '88 Fox Coupe (Wexford)

  »« »

Sounds like a starter solenoid. It pushes the starter pinion onto the ring gear on the flywheel.

This happens simultaneously with the contacts for the starter motor though so you wouldn't think that the motor would spin if the solenoid didn't move.

Someone more knowledgeable with starters help.

Modified by DubbyDriver at 3:41 PM 4-3-2008



Quote, originally posted by Dubbin_B4 »
i would like my click back.

snowfox
Member

Offline

Member Since
4-4-2002
4419 posts

Livermore CA
1989 Fox Wagon, 89 Jetta Wolfsburg, 99 Passat GLX - the baby hauler

 Re: Starter spinning freely but not engaging (sold on expense) »« »

<raises hand>

Me, too - except most times, the second turn of the key gets it workin' just fine. Mines been like this since, uh, I can't remember when... A long time, though.



Quote, originally posted by kerensky »
It's a direct swap. Just be sure to get the 5 speed linkage, as the two are different. And replace the bushings in the new linkage while you've got it apart. And a new clutch/CV joints/bearings/brake rotors/engine swap/paint job/interior refresh, because, you know, while you're in there you might as well.

kerensky
Member



Offline

Member Since
3-5-2001
4234 posts

Norman OK
"Prime Minista" of Gullible

 Re: Starter spinning freely but not engaging (snowfox) »« »

Quote, originally posted by snowfox »
<raises hand>

Me, too - except most times, the second turn of the key gets it workin' just fine. Mines been like this since, uh, I can't remember when... A long time, though.

Never had this happen to me with a VW product, but happens with Chebbies 'n Fords a lot. Often times a good solid whack to the starter with a ball-peen hammer is enough to get it working again for awhile.



Chad Mitchell ** '89 Fox GLSport 4-dr ** '89 Fox GL'Sport' wagon
Quote, originally posted by snowfox »
I dub thee "Prime Minista" ...
Quote, originally posted by Longitudinal »
Imagine mounting a VR in a rabbit, double it, and you'd be getting close. And before you think "that doesn't sound that hard," I am referring to an actual rabbit--with pointy ears and a bushy tail.

Windowlicker
Member



Offline

Member Since
9-23-2004
3908 posts

San Francisco CA
see signature

 Re: Starter spinning freely but not engaging (kerensky) »« »

Get out your parachute pants cause it's HAMMER TIME!





'creepy drugged out ice cream eating diesel vw driving east coast transplant' - Banned Wagon

I am Stinky Whizzleteats

1998 MKIII Jetta TDI
1993 Wolfsburg Edition Fox: 2.0L 16v (gone pending Jamie picking it up)
1984 MKI Rabbit GTI
1984 Porsche 944 Eurospec

http://www.vwfox.net

DubbyDriver
Member



Offline

Member Since
10-23-2003
1228 posts

St. Paul MN
99.5 2.slow jetta(Bebe), '88 Fox Coupe (Wexford)

  »« »

Can't touch this!



Quote, originally posted by Dubbin_B4 »
i would like my click back.

adrian8426
Member



Offline

Member Since
12-29-2007
482 posts

San Juan PR
1993 VW Fox - 1993 Passat Wagon VR6 - 2003 Eclipse Spyder GTS - 2002 Hyundai SantaFe

  »« »

Buy a starter, don't be a cheapo like myself that instead bought a hard rubber mallet as a precaution. After a while, you'll end up with the selonoid on the floor.
kerensky
Member



Offline

Member Since
3-5-2001
4234 posts

Norman OK
"Prime Minista" of Gullible

 Re: (adrian8426) »« »

Quote, originally posted by adrian8426 »
Buy a starter, don't be a cheapo like myself that instead bought a hard rubber mallet as a precaution. After a while, you'll end up with the selonoid on the floor.
Yeah, the Hammer Protocol is only recommended as a stop-gap measure, intended to get you to next payday or whatever so you can then purchase a new starter.



Chad Mitchell ** '89 Fox GLSport 4-dr ** '89 Fox GL'Sport' wagon
Quote, originally posted by snowfox »
I dub thee "Prime Minista" ...
Quote, originally posted by Longitudinal »
Imagine mounting a VR in a rabbit, double it, and you'd be getting close. And before you think "that doesn't sound that hard," I am referring to an actual rabbit--with pointy ears and a bushy tail.

snowfox
Member

Offline

Member Since
4-4-2002
4419 posts

Livermore CA
1989 Fox Wagon, 89 Jetta Wolfsburg, 99 Passat GLX - the baby hauler

 Re: (kerensky) »« »

I've seen dozens and dozens and dozens of paydays go by since mine started doing this... When I said it's been doing it for a long time, I'm taling about something like 3-5 years. Kinda makes me wonder if I just need to get down in there and check some groundage...



Quote, originally posted by kerensky »
It's a direct swap. Just be sure to get the 5 speed linkage, as the two are different. And replace the bushings in the new linkage while you've got it apart. And a new clutch/CV joints/bearings/brake rotors/engine swap/paint job/interior refresh, because, you know, while you're in there you might as well.

88vwFox
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-22-2005
1525 posts

Melbourne FL
1981 VW rabbit 2 door auto, 1981 VW rabbit 4 door 5 speed, 1988 vw fox wagon +1658 posts

 Re: (DubbyDriver) »« »

Quote, originally posted by DubbyDriver »
Can't touch this!

OH, OH OH OH, OH, OH!



93 VW Fox 2 door = RIP (totaled 06-03-08)
88 VW Fox wagon 2 door = IT RUNS! now for sale. Build thread---> http://forums.vwvortex.com/zerothread?id=4432862
81 VW Rabbit 2 door = 1.8l 8v swap, 3 speed auto
81 VW Rabbit 4 door = Parts car FREE!
adrian8426
Member



Offline

Member Since
12-29-2007
482 posts

San Juan PR
1993 VW Fox - 1993 Passat Wagon VR6 - 2003 Eclipse Spyder GTS - 2002 Hyundai SantaFe

  »« »

LOL! I was watching MTV's Breaking the Cradle while reading this and just as I was reading HAMMER TIME, MC Hammer appeared on the tv. Freaky.
OmniGLHLover
Member



Offline

Member Since
3-13-2006
177 posts

Fountain CO
1990 Fox, 85 GLH Omni with 60 trim turbo, gutted and Azenis-work in progress

 Re: (adrian8426) »« »

the drive systems on starters are really simple but they can fail in a few different ways.

if the starter is spinning freely, the drive is fudged ~or~ the flywheel is missing teeth.
i havent torn into a fox starter, so im not sure if they have an arm that pulls the gear into the flywheel,or if theyre the kind that does it automaticly when energized.
Another thing, when you turn off your engine, the flywheel stops at one of four(4) places in relation to the starter gear. so if one of those four is missing a few teeth, it would make the problem intermittent.

the starter is on the passenger side of the car, right behind the motor mount. The book says you gotta drop the subframe a little on cars with AC in order to get the starter out. some say it can be done without any of that. Once its out spin the drive gear, it should only tune one way freely, and when spun the other way, it should engage and turn the shaft in the starter. If it spins freely both ways, your starter drive is the probem, buy new starter.

i havent had a rpoblem with my fox starter specifically so if any of this is wrong, correct me gurus.





OldVanagon:
"The FAQs seem like a bunch of ghetto girls on the jerry springer show fighting over "'das mah baybeez daddy!"
rpkilgor
Member

Offline

Member Since
2-25-2007
250 posts

Bloomington IN
89 Fox Gl

 Re: Starter spinning freely but not engaging (kerensky) »« »

I wish I had known about this hammer trick a couple days ago. I never had a problem with a fox starter, but I just replaced the starter on my rust bucket chevy cavalier. Banging on the car with a hammer really would have gone well with the overall aesthetic of the car. extreme rust, crumpled hood (i was hit by a flying boxspring once on Interstate 70), and a broken headlight mount... the way the headlight sits it kind of looks like the car has a black eye.



Quote, originally posted by Longitudinal »

Oh, and german plates on Brazilian cars? Meh.

Homer: Kids, how would you like to go... to Blockoland! Bart & Lisa: Meh. Homer: But the TV gave the impression that-- Bart: We said "meh". Lisa: M-E-H.

kerensky
Member



Offline

Member Since
3-5-2001
4234 posts

Norman OK
"Prime Minista" of Gullible

 Re: Starter spinning freely but not engaging (rpkilgor) »« »

Quote, originally posted by rpkilgor »
i was hit by a flying boxspring once on Interstate 70
Whoa, now that'll get your attention in a hurry....



Chad Mitchell ** '89 Fox GLSport 4-dr ** '89 Fox GL'Sport' wagon
Quote, originally posted by snowfox »
I dub thee "Prime Minista" ...
Quote, originally posted by Longitudinal »
Imagine mounting a VR in a rabbit, double it, and you'd be getting close. And before you think "that doesn't sound that hard," I am referring to an actual rabbit--with pointy ears and a bushy tail.

DubbyDriver
Member



Offline

Member Since
10-23-2003
1228 posts

St. Paul MN
99.5 2.slow jetta(Bebe), '88 Fox Coupe (Wexford)

 Re: (88vwFox) »« »

Quote, originally posted by 88vwFox »

OH, OH OH OH, OH, OH!

A super dope homeboy from the hometown!

I told ya homeboyeee. Ya can't touch this!

http://video.google.com/videop...dex=0

Ahh the good old days, when rap was actually a genre of music.



Quote, originally posted by Dubbin_B4 »
i would like my click back.

2925
Member



Offline

Member Since
12-10-2007
786 posts

CV CA
1990 g60 corrado

  »« »

To get to a starter out on a fox, or atleast a fox II

its right behind the A/C
undo the four bolts holding the A/C on and let it free hang, the tube are strong enough to let it hang.

from there you just unbolt the start, its 3 bolts.

and bam its off.
well of course with a hole lot of wiggling.


the starters, when energized, are pushed to meet the flywheel.

if you get a new start remember, where the rotor is pushed is a little grommit, or washer sort of thing, its a bitch to get out, either have a smallish screwdriver to tear it up and pull it out in chunks like i did, or a smaller wooden dowel works from what ive read.

davedavetc
Member

Offline

Member Since
2-22-2008
6 posts

Cranston RI

 Re: (DubbyDriver) »« »

hahaa
» Return to Fox
Quick Reply

ZeroForum 2.1.2. ©2008 RelyNet, Inc.

For advertising information Click Here